The Stormwater Blogs

More from this blogger

Stormwater Editor's Blog

  • RSS
  • Save
  • Print
  • Email
Tuesday, February 07, 2012 8:00 AM

Too Easy Being Green?

By: Kaspersen, Janice: Stormwater Editor Comments

For all of us who’ve ever felt a little smug (and even trendy) about doing the right things for the environment, this article is a gentle poke in the ribs. Its premise is that many middle-class or affluent people feel better about themselves for such acts as buying a new fuel-efficient car or for becoming “locavores”—eating only food that’s produced within a short distance of where it’s consumed, thereby saving energy costs to transport it. But the author cautions against false savings and hidden costs to the environment: “Locavorism is appealing because it feels enlightened but entails no actual sacrifice. A colleague of mine produces her own eggs by raising chickens in her backyard. But she also drives individual hens to the veterinarian, giving her breakfasts an impressively huge carbon footprint.”

Consumption itself, he argues, is the problem. He cites a flight he recently took from Melbourne to New York; each passenger’s share of the fuel consumed on that single flight was “greater than the total amount of energy that the average resident of the Earth uses, for all purposes, in a year.” The solution, he says, isn’t to make planes more fuel efficient but to travel less. And this applies to everything from vehicles (forget the Prius and use public transportation instead, he advises) to more-efficient lighting.

How does this view apply to our own field? Take the problem of combined sewer overflows, for example. It’s now common practice in many places to use green infrastructure to reduce CSOs and avoid or delay the building of new treatment plants. This is a welcome trend, economically and environmentally. If the pace of development continues, though, eventually all the bioswales and permeable pavements and other infiltration measures won’t be enough to offset the increased runoff. What’s the solution? We can’t cause it to rain less. Two possible remedies—either using less water for household, commercial, industrial, and irrigation needs, and therefore sending less of it to the sanitary sewer system, or else limiting the amount or type of development that’s allowed—are beyond the scope of the stormwater manager.

To what extent do you think consumption—of water in particular, and of fuel and other commodities in general—should be a stormwater concern?

****************

Upcoming Forester University Webinars

February 9th, 2012
Differentiating & Monitoring Groundwater Plumes
Threatened by various plumes of mobile contaminants, urban potable groundwater resources require groundwater professionals to not only determine the source of individual plumes, but apportion the contributions of multiple sources within a composite plume. Join William G. Soukup, P.G. of Cornerstone Environmental Group LLC to discuss the analytical and interpretive techniques for differentiating plumes and their sources, as well as tips to improve long-term plume monitoring and management. Read More...

February 23rd, 2012
Stormwater Pond BMP Management: Design, Operation & Maintenance
Stormwater ponds are one of the most common urban rainwater runoff BMPs thanks to their reliability and predictability, but performance is design and maintenance dependent. Join Shahram (Shane) Missaghi of the University of Minnesota to explore stormwater pond design, operation and maintenance presented in an integrated stormwater pond management plan that effectively manages your stormwater and protects the water quality of your natural resources. Read More...

What Do You Think?

Tom Smith

Thursday, February 09, 2012

I would like to see rainwater harvesting (RWH) gain the popularity in the U.S. that is has in Europe, Australia and the Caribbean. RWH is a great way to reduce the use of potable water for flushing and irrigation while at the same time reducing stormwater runoff.

drwatershed

Thursday, February 09, 2012

Your observation that CSO and policy changes to increase capacity are beyond the scope of the "stormwater manager" is totally fallacious. Combined Sewer Systems have more than enough capacity for dry weather sanitary flow in all but a few extreme cases. The problem is the storm water that gets in to the system whether intentionally as designed in a CSO system or unintentionally through I&I. Either way the stormwater is what causes the overflow. Typically new development stnadards will require technology and desing specs that will result in less I&I and therefore overflow, so if Cities with CSO have development it is a benefit to their "greeness" not a detriment since they will then have the economic revenue to address their aging infrastructure problems.

Your point about controlling development is on target and linking all these things together is what everyone markets as sustainable planning. For that we have to think on an even broader scale and control development in arid areas and encourage development where water resources are available. Bringing development back to shrinking CSO communities will bring revenue back to address stormwater and overflow issues. The shrinking eastern cities have more potential to create "greener" communities than the arid west, inherently because of water and air conditioning needs let alone greater commute distances and less public transportation.

Your point about it being "Too easy" to be green is obviously correct as you have fallen into an oversimplified solution in your application of a CSO example.

Anonymous

Thursday, February 09, 2012

Janice hit the nail on the head with her comments on locavorism - as long as we have the "disposable income" to drive to work, fly on vacations, and pay a little more for local produce people will do those "little things" to feel good about driving a greener car and eating only local foods.

VV

Wednesday, February 08, 2012

Green roofs are an excellent solution to stormwater run-off in cities. Have a look at www.oikosteges.gr or www.vveco.eu (for English)

Post a Comment

Note from Beth Tompkins, Director of Education & Training: The content that appears in our "Comments" section is supplied to us by outside, third-party readers and organizations and  does not necessarily reflect the view of our staff or Forester Media—in fact, we may not agree with it—and we do not endorse, warrant, or otherwise take responsibility for any content supplied by third parties that appear on our website. “All comments are subject to approval

CAPTCHA Validation
CAPTCHA
Code:

 

Stormwater Email Updates!

Get weekly news and updates through our Water Efficiency email newsletter!